← All posts

Extend or pay bank guarantee: what to do when the contractor asks for an extension

Published

An extend or pay demand is a full demand for payment under the guarantee that also offers the guarantor an alternative: extend the expiry to a stated date instead of paying. Under Article 23 of URDG 758 the guarantor may hold payment for up to 30 calendar days while the principal arranges the extension. If the guarantee is extended for the period you asked for, the demand is treated as withdrawn. If it is not, the guarantor pays on the demand already in hand. That is why a beneficiary uses it when a contractor asks for more time and the guarantee is about to expire: only the guarantor can extend a guarantee, by issuing an amendment before expiry, and once a guarantee has expired nothing can bring it back.

We have found no court decision on Article 23 itself. What there is: the rules, ICC’s ISDGP and a few decisions on neighbouring questions.

Can a bank guarantee be extended?

Yes, but only by an amendment the guarantor issues while the guarantee is still alive: an expired one cannot be extended.

Under URDG 758 an extension is an amendment (Article 11). An amendment binds the beneficiary only once it agrees to it, but it binds the guarantor as soon as it is issued. For an extension this almost always helps the beneficiary, but check that nothing else changed with the date, such as the amount or the demand conditions.

The rules themselves do not govern extensions on request. ISDGP (paras 186–187) says such a term works if the guarantee includes it, and that a request to extend must arrive before expiry. The request does not have to look like a demand, but it does not replace one either.

A contractor’s promise to extend is not an extension. The expiry moves only when the guarantor has issued the amendment and you have it.

Extend, demand payment or extend or pay: how do you choose?

It turns on two questions: has the contractor broken the contract, and do you still need the contractor on site? The dates matter less than the risk of being left with no security at all.

A teaching example. “Your company” is building a plant, and the construction contract is secured by a performance guarantee from Banque Hélvane SA (Paris branch) subject to URDG 758. Works are behind schedule and the guarantee will expire before completion. The contractor writes to your treasury: the bank is ready to extend, it only needs your consent, and the amendment will come through in a few days. Treasury has to decide whether to wait for the amendment or to present a demand.

  • The contractor is performing, the delay is agreed and the bank has issued the amendment. Accept the amendment. There is close to no risk if it arrived before expiry.
  • The contractor promises an extension, there is no amendment yet and expiry is close. Present extend or pay. The demand must be complete: a defect costs you the payment.
  • The contractor is in breach and the relationship is over. Demand payment. Expect a dispute with the contractor, possibly a claim of abusive calling.
  • Obligations are performed and the risk has gone. Let the guarantee expire. No risk.

The danger is waiting in the second situation instead of using extend or pay. The contractor may honestly believe the bank will extend. The bank may not: extending the guarantee extends its own exposure to the contractor, and the decision is the bank’s. If the answer comes after expiry, your security has already gone.

Extend or pay removes that risk: the demand is in before expiry, and the bank then chooses between extending and paying. Both outcomes work for the beneficiary.

How does extend or pay work under Article 23 of URDG 758?

The beneficiary presents a complying demand for payment and, in the same demand, offers an extension as the alternative. The guarantor can then hold back payment, but for 30 calendar days at most (Article 23(a)). If within that time the guarantee is extended for the period you asked for, the demand is treated as withdrawn. If not, the guarantor pays.

What this means for the beneficiary:

  • No fresh demand is needed. If there is no extension, the guarantor pays on the demand already presented. You do not repeat it or update the documents, even if a document went out of date during the suspension (ISDGP, para. 136).
  • The guarantor may refuse to extend even when the contractor instructs it to. It must then pay (Article 23(e)).
  • No interest is due for the suspension: the guarantor is not liable for it (Article 23(e)–(g); ISDGP, para. 137).
  • No second demand for the full amount can be made while the suspension runs. If the first demand was for everything available, you wait for the guarantor’s decision. If it was for part of the amount and the guarantee allows several demands, you can demand the rest separately (ISDGP, paras 131–133).
  • Article 23(a) sets the suspension period, and the beneficiary cannot make its demand conditional on a different period from the one in Article 23(a); only the guarantee itself can change it (ISDGP, paras 128–129).

If the guarantee is extended for a shorter period than you asked for, the rules give no direct answer. On the wording of Article 23(d), the demand falls away only if the extension matches the one requested or you agreed to it. If that happens, take it to your lawyer.

What should an extend or pay demand contain?

Everything an ordinary demand contains, plus the exact extension period. An extend or pay demand is examined as strictly as any demand, and a discrepancy costs you both the payment and the extension.

Under ISDGP (paras 122–124) the demand needs:

  • a request for payment with the amount in the guarantee currency;
  • the Article 15(a) statement of how the contractor is in breach;
  • any documents the guarantee calls for;
  • the new expiry date or the extension period you will accept.

If there is no period, the guarantor will ask you for one. If you stay silent until the suspension ends, the guarantor may handle it simply as a demand for payment (ISDGP, para. 123). A “pay or hold the money” option does not exist under the rules, and the beneficiary cannot use one (ISDGP, paras 122–124).

The breach does not need a detailed account. In DOCDEX 374 the beneficiary presented an extend or pay demand under an advance payment guarantee, stating that the principal had failed to perform and had not repaid the advance. The guarantor rejected it for lack of detail about the breach. The DOCDEX experts held that Article 15(a) asks for no detail and that a statement in the form the guarantee required was enough. How to build the demand itself, and where beneficiaries usually go wrong, is covered in our article on URDG 758 Article 15.

Example wording, not a template for use:

Example wording

We demand payment under guarantee No. [guarantee number] of [amount and currency]. The contractor has failed to perform construction contract No. [number as in the guarantee] dated [date as in the guarantee]: the works for [stage] were not completed by the contractual date. As an alternative to payment, we agree to an extension of the guarantee until [new expiry date].

The last sentence names a specific date. Without it the guarantor will come back to ask, and the suspension period goes on correspondence.

Why doesn’t a request to extend protect you without a demand?

A request to extend is not a demand for payment. If no extension is given and the guarantee expires, there is nothing left to claim under.

The English case British Arab Commercial Bank v Bank of Communications concerned a chain of guarantees for a dam project, and the counter-guarantees required the beneficiary’s demand to arrive by a set date. Only a request to extend the guarantee arrived in time. The English court held that a demand means a demand for payment, a request to extend is not one, and neither bank in the chain had to pay. URDG did not apply to those guarantees, but the conclusion matches the logic of Article 23: only a demand for payment preserves your rights.

So a letter asking the contractor or the bank to extend is fine while expiry is far off. When it is close, you need an alternative that includes payment, which is what extend or pay is.

Is extend or pay an abusive call?

Not if the breach you state is real. The statement of breach is your assertion, and if the contractor goes to court, you are the one who has to stand behind it.

Extend or pay is often used when the contractor is still working but the guarantee runs out before the works do. What matters then is whether the contract obliges the contractor to keep the guarantee valid until completion. In the Australian case Clough Engineering v Oil and Natural Gas Corporation, the contractor sought an injunction to stop the employer calling the performance guarantees. The court refused: the contractor had itself broken its contractual duty to extend the guarantees, and the employer’s call was made in good faith. URDG did not apply, and the dispute turned on the contract and Australian law.

Under Russian law, abuse is argued under Article 10 of the Civil Code when a beneficiary calls the guarantee although it knows the contractor has performed. If the contractor has done everything and the delay is not its fault, an extend or pay demand with a statement of breach becomes a risk for you. Agree the extension early instead and do not leave it to the last days.

What if the guarantee is not subject to URDG 758?

Without URDG, there may be no extend or pay mechanism at all unless the guarantee itself sets one out. Russian law is a good example: the Civil Code has no special rule for it.

If a guarantee governed only by the Russian Civil Code says nothing about extend or pay, the bank handles your letter as an ordinary demand for payment. It has five days to examine it, and the guarantee may set up to 30 days (Article 375). The law provides no 30-day suspension to arrange an extension. Under such a guarantee, send the request to extend separately and early, and present a demand for payment as a demand if the extension has not come through in time.

Short checklist when the contractor asks for an extension

  1. Check which rules the guarantee is subject to: URDG 758 or local law only.
  2. Check the construction contract: is the contractor obliged to keep the guarantee extended?
  3. If the extension is agreed, wait for the guarantor’s amendment, not the contractor’s letter, and check everything in the amendment besides the date.
  4. If there is no amendment and expiry is close, prepare extend or pay with a full set of documents and an exact new expiry date.
  5. If the contractor is in breach and you will not keep working with it, demand payment.
  6. Present it to the guarantor by the delivery channel the guarantee sets, early enough to arrive before expiry.

A URDG practice simulator, where you can work through this choice on training scenarios, is in preparation.

Sources

  • URDG 758, arts 11, 15(a), 23 (paraphrased)
  • ISDGP, paras 122–137, 186–187 (paraphrased; numbering from the online edition)
  • Russian Civil Code, arts 10, 371, 375
  • DOCDEX Decision 374
  • Clough Engineering Ltd v Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd, [2008] FCAFC 136
  • British Arab Commercial Bank plc v Bank of Communications, [2011] EWHC 281 (Comm)